Clyde mays vs buffalo trace
Today we talk about Clyde mays vs buffalo trace.
Introduction to Clyde Mays and Buffalo Trace
As a bourbon enthusiast, my passion for this rich and complex spirit has led me to explore various brands, particularly Clyde Mays and Buffalo Trace. Both bourbons have their unique stories and flavor profiles that make them stand out in the crowded bourbon market. In this article, I’ll provide a detailed comparison of these two noteworthy bourbons through tasting notes, pricing, and more to help you make an informed choice.
Overview of Clyde Mays Bourbon
Clyde Mays bourbon, produced by Conecuh Ridge Distillery in Alabama, is celebrated for its unusual aging process, which involves finishing in apple brandy barrels. This method introduces a sweeter, fruity note to the bourbon, resulting in a unique product that appeals to those with an affinity for sweeter spirits. In 2022, Clyde Mays had a production volume of around 10,000 cases, making it a small but significant player in the bourbon scene.
Overview of Buffalo Trace Bourbon
Buffalo Trace, produced in Frankfort, Kentucky, is renowned for its quality and consistency. The distillery is one of the oldest in the United States, with its roots dating back to 1773. As one of the top-selling bourbons, Buffalo Trace produced over 1.1 million cases in 2022. Its balanced flavor and historical heritage make it a staple for bourbon lovers, and it has earned numerous awards at prestigious competitions.
Tasting Notes
Flavor Profile of Clyde Mays
- Sweet apple pie notes due to apple brandy seasoning.
- Prominent vanilla and caramel flavors characteristic of bourbon.
- A subtle spiciness that adds complexity and depth.
When I first tried Clyde Mays, the sweetness pleasantly surprised me. The apple pie flavor lingers, complementing its warm spices beautifully.
Flavor Profile of Buffalo Trace
- Rich vanilla and caramel, blending beautifully with oak.
- Complex notes of cherry, cocoa, and baking spices.
- A well-rounded, smooth finish that can last for several seconds.
Tasting Buffalo Trace was a revelation for me. Its rich and balanced flavor profiles made every sip enjoyable and created a unique experience that I couldn’t wait to repeat.
Comparison of Alcohol Content
Clyde Mays Alcohol Percentage
Clyde Mays typically comes in at 43% ABV (86 proof). While this percentage is standard for bourbon, it provides just the right balance between flavor intensity and drinkability. For me, it’s perfect for sipping neat, allowing all those flavors to shine.
Buffalo Trace Alcohol Percentage
Buffalo Trace has a slightly higher alcohol content, usually at 45% ABV (90 proof). This gives it a more robust profile that reveals richer flavors and a bold finish. Personally, I enjoy it neat or on the rocks to fully appreciate its complexity.
Overall Aroma
Aroma Characteristics of Clyde Mays
Clyde Mays has an inviting aroma with fruity notes evident right out of the bottle. The combination of apple and oak creates a warm and inviting scent, reminiscent of a cozy kitchen. I find this aroma quite comforting and engaging, drawing me in for that first sip.
Aroma Characteristics of Buffalo Trace
Buffalo Trace presents a rich bouquet dominated by vanilla and caramel, underlined by hints of oak and a touch of spice. The complexity of the aroma enhances its appeal, making it feel luxurious from the moment I pour it. This blend often makes me feel nostalgic, as I associate it with fine gatherings and good company.
Texture and Mouthfeel
Texture Experience with Clyde Mays
When tasting Clyde Mays, I immediately notice its smooth texture that feels gentle on the palate—a testament to its careful crafting. I also detect a slight oiliness, leading to a satisfying mouthfeel that lingers pleasantly.
Texture Experience with Buffalo Trace
Buffalo Trace provides a creamier mouthfeel that envelops the palate, making each sip quite fulfilling. The viscosity enhances its rich flavor notes, which resonate well with both novices and bourbon aficionados alike.
Pricing Comparison
Price Point for Clyde Mays
Clyde Mays is generally available for around $30 to $40 per bottle, which offers great value for the unique experience it delivers. Given its small-batch production, this bourbon is both accessible and reasonably priced compared to other craft options.
Price Point for Buffalo Trace
Buffalo Trace tends to retail between $25 and $35. Its pricing makes it an excellent choice for both new bourbon drinkers and seasoned enthusiasts. The combination of quality and affordability often leads to sold-out shelves—especially at popular retailers.
Serving Suggestions
Best Ways to Enjoy Clyde Mays
I recommend enjoying Clyde Mays neat or with a single ice cube. This dilution allows its unique flavors to breathe and evolve. Its sweetness makes it a delightful choice for a bourbon-based dessert cocktail, too.
Best Ways to Enjoy Buffalo Trace
Buffalo Trace is spectacular both neat and in cocktails. I’ve often used it in classic bourbon drinks like an Old Fashioned or a Manhattan, which showcase its versatility while highlighting its robust flavors.
Food Pairing Recommendations
Pairing Clyde Mays with Foods
- Maple-glazed roasted chicken.
- Spiced apple pie.
- Vanilla ice cream topped with caramel drizzle.
These pairings bring out the sweetness of Clyde Mays, creating a truly harmonious dining experience.
Pairing Buffalo Trace with Foods
- Smoked brisket with a smoky barbecue sauce.
- Dark chocolate torte.
- Sharp cheddar cheese.
Buffalo Trace’s bold flavor pairs beautifully with rich and savory dishes, enhancing each element of the meal.
Consumer Ratings and Reviews
Customer Feedback on Clyde Mays
Consumers often rave about Clyde Mays for its distinct flavor profile and unique apple notes. With an average rating of 4.2 out of 5 stars among bourbon lovers on sites like distillery-wise and whiskey advocate, it stands out as a beloved choice in craft bourbons.
Customer Feedback on Buffalo Trace
Buffalo Trace consistently garners high praise, with many labeling it as a benchmark bourbon. Its average rating across various platforms is around 4.4 stars, reflecting its popularity and appeal to a wide audience.
Conclusion: Which One Reigns Supreme?
Final Thoughts on Clyde Mays
Ultimately, Clyde Mays carved a niche for itself with its unique sweetness and innovation. It resonates with those who appreciate creative flavors that evoke nostalgia, making it ideal for special occasions.
Final Thoughts on Buffalo Trace
Buffalo Trace, with its deep-rooted history and balanced profile, remains my go-to bourbon. Its reliability and adaptability to various cocktails make it a constant presence in my home bar.
Where to Buy
Purchasing Clyde Mays
I typically find Clyde Mays at local liquor stores and online retailers like Drizly or Total Wine. It is becoming more readily available, so check your nearest store for stock.
Purchasing Buffalo Trace
Buffalo Trace is widely available and can be found at most liquor retailers, both locally and online. Its popularity means you can often find it without much hassle.
Recommendations for Similar Bourbons
Alternatives to Clyde Mays
- Angel’s Envy – similar in sweetness due to aging in wine barrels.
- Wild Turkey 101 – known for its boldness and spice.
- Four Roses Small Batch – a well-balanced, fruity option.
Alternatives to Buffalo Trace
- Evan Williams Black Label – a value bourbon with rich flavor.
- Basil Hayden’s – a smooth alternative with a slightly lower proof.
- Buffalo Trace’s own Eagle Rare – a single barrel selection worth exploring.
FAQ
Where does Buffalo Trace rank among bourbons?
Buffalo Trace ranks among the top bourbons globally, often described as a benchmark in the industry, due to its quality, taste, and consistency.
Who owns Clyde Mays whiskey?
Clyde Mays whiskey is produced by Conecuh Ridge Distillery, owned by the Mays family, ensuring that the legacy of its namesake continues.
What bourbon is like Buffalo Trace?
Bourbons like Blanton’s and Eagle Rare share similar flavor profiles with Buffalo Trace, making them excellent alternatives for those who enjoy that classic bourbon essence.
Is Benchmark made by Buffalo Trace?
Yes, Benchmark Bourbon is produced by Buffalo Trace Distillery, and it is recognized for its smoothness and affordability, appealing to many bourbon drinkers.
