Makers mark vs bulleit vs buffalo trace
Today we talk about Makers mark vs bulleit vs buffalo trace.
As someone deeply passionate about bourbon, I constantly find myself exploring the rich and complex world of spirits, particularly when it comes to iconic brands like Maker’s Mark, Bulleit, and Buffalo Trace. Each of these brands has earned its reputation through unique offerings, but how do they truly compare? In this article, we’ll dive into specific details concerning ownership, mashbills, maturation processes, and more, to help you find the bourbon that perfectly suits your taste.
Round 1: Ownership
Maker’s Mark Ownership
Maker’s Mark is owned by Beam Suntory, part of the larger Suntory Holdings. This parent company acquired Maker’s Mark in 2014 for a reported $13.6 billion. The brand retains its craft traditions, which can be traced back to Bill Samuels, Sr., who started it in 1953. This connection to family-run business practices lends a unique authenticity that resonates with consumers like me.
Bulleit Ownership
Bulleit Bourbon belongs to Diageo, a colossal player in the spirits industry, with annual sales exceeding $17 billion in 2020. Founded in the 1830s, it was re-launched in the 1990s by Tom Bulleit, aimed at honoring his great-great-grandfather. The backing of Diageo has allowed Bulleit to thrive, making it one of the top-selling bourbon brands in the U.S., with market share growing steadily.
Buffalo Trace Ownership
Buffalo Trace is produced at the Buffalo Trace Distillery, which is owned by Sazerac Company. This distillery has been operational since 1773 and is recognized for producing multiple award-winning bourbons. With over 1.1 million barrels of bourbon aging on-site, Buffalo Trace’s rich history and tradition offer a quality assurance that speaks to me and many bourbon lovers worldwide.
Round 2: Mashbills
Maker’s Mark Mashbill
Maker’s Mark employs a mashbill of 70% corn, 16% wheat, and 14% barley. The inclusion of wheat rather than rye is significant; it creates a softer, rounder flavor profile that made it a favorite of 25% of bourbon drinkers surveyed in 2022 according to the Distilled Spirits Council of the U.S.
Bulleit Mashbill
Bulleit boasts a high rye mashbill of 68% corn, 28% rye, and 4% barley. This gives it that characteristic spicy kick, appealing to bourbon enthusiasts who prefer a bolder taste. The high rye content is a major draw for roughly 30% of bourbon drinkers who seek something with a bit more edge.
Buffalo Trace Mashbill
The mashbill at Buffalo Trace is shrouded in some mystery, though it’s commonly believed to be around 60% corn, 10% rye, and 30% malted barley. This combination leads to a balanced flavor profile, appealing to both new and seasoned bourbon aficionados. According to industry reports, Buffalo Trace has gained a significant percentage of new bourbon drinkers, with 15% choosing it as their first experience.
Round 3: Maturation
Maker’s Mark Maturation Process
Maker’s Mark undergoes its aging process in charred oak barrels, typically for at least six years. This lengthy maturation period results in a complicated flavor profile that appeals to many bourbon lovers, as evidenced by a 2022 survey showing that 70% of respondents value bourbon that has been aged for over five years.
Bulleit Maturation Process
Bulleit is generally aged for a minimum of six years, but many barrels are held longer. This contributes to its spicy and robust flavor. In blind tastings, Bulleit consistently scores high in favorability, with 78% of tasters noting its complexity, indicating that aging plays a critical role in its allure.
Buffalo Trace Maturation Process
Buffalo Trace’s maturation range is 8 to 12 years, providing a diverse selection of flavor profiles across different batches. This versatility is one reason Buffalo Trace has taken home over 500 awards since 2000, making it highly appreciated in the bourbon community.
Round 4: Distillation & Production
Maker’s Mark Production Techniques
Maker’s Mark utilizes a traditional pot still for its initial distillation. This method promotes quality over quantity, aligning with its branding of handcrafted bourbon. Each batch consists of 1,000 gallons, a small batch by industry standards, giving it a level of intimacy and care that resonates with me.
Bulleit Production Techniques
Bulleit utilizes a continuous column still for its production. This method ensures efficiency while maintaining the high flavor profile that bourbon lovers crave. Reports indicate that Bulleit’s consistency in quality puts it among the top 10% of spirit brands across the globe.
Buffalo Trace Production Techniques
Buffalo Trace’s distillation process combines pot and column stills, leading to unique flavor development. They are firmly committed to craftsmanship, reflected in the fact that 60% of their barrels are sourced from within 120 miles of the distillery, supporting local producers and reducing environmental impact.
Round 5: Price Point & Value
Maker’s Mark Pricing
Maker’s Mark typically retails for $25-$35 per 750ml bottle, making it a relatively affordable luxury. Given that it’s often rated above 90 points in various bourbon reviews, the price point offers incredible value for quality.
Bulleit Pricing
Bulleit aligns closely with Maker’s Mark in price, usually found in the $25-$30 range. This price is supported by its high rye content and consistently favorable reviews, making it a popular choice among cocktail enthusiasts.
Buffalo Trace Pricing
Buffalo Trace prices itself around $20-$25, making it one of the best value bourbons on the market. The growing demand has led to lower availability, but still, it frequently tops lists of sought-after bourbons for its quality relative to cost.
Round 6: Tasting Notes
Maker’s Mark Tasting Notes
During my tasting experiences, Maker’s Mark often reveals to me notes of rich caramel, vanilla, and light spice. Its smoothness makes it perfect for sipping or mixing in classic cocktails. According to Wine Enthusiast, it enjoys a consistent score of around 90 points.
Bulleit Tasting Notes
In contrast, Bulleit hits my palate with a combination of spicy rye, vanilla, and oak flavors. The bold spiciness reflected in tasting notes makes it ideal for robust cocktails. I find its typical score around 88 points in spirits rankings highlights its strong presence among bourbon drinkers.
Buffalo Trace Tasting Notes
Buffalo Trace rounds out my bourbon journey with its complex notes of caramel, brown sugar, and a peppery finish. This complexity often results in a solid 93-point rating in blind tastings, showcasing its high quality and allure.
Round 7: Mixing & Pairing Recommendations
Best Cocktails with Maker’s Mark
- Mint Julep – Perfectly crafted with muddled mint leaves and crushed ice, made more interesting with Maker’s Mark’s smoothness.
- Old Fashioned – Combining bitters, sugar, and a twist of orange, the subtle complexity of Maker’s Mark excels here.
Best Cocktails with Bulleit
- Bulleit Manhattan – Perfectly mixed with sweet vermouth and a hint of cherry, showcasing Bulleit’s high-rye profile.
- Bourbon Sour – Complemented with lemon juice and sugar, this cocktail brings out Bulleit’s robust character nicely.
Best Cocktails with Buffalo Trace
- Buffalo Trace Old Fashioned – A classic with a rich twist, highlighting Buffalo Trace’s smoothness and depth.
- Buffalo Trace Sour – A cocktail that brings together lemon and sugar, pairing beautifully with Buffalo Trace’s complex flavors.
Round 8: Flavor Profiles
Flavor Profile of Maker’s Mark
Maker’s Mark provides a creamy, sweet profile characterized by caramel, vanilla, and a soft spice. For many, including myself, this approachable flavor is an inviting starting point in the bourbon world.
Flavor Profile of Bulleit
Bulleit delivers a punchy, spicy experience with a boldness attributed to its high rye content. The balance of oak and sweetness makes it attractive, particularly to those who enjoy a sharper bourbon.
Flavor Profile of Buffalo Trace
Buffalo Trace embodies a well-rounded and rich flavor, melding sweet caramel, vanilla, and a gentle smokiness. It’s versatile, perfect for sipping neat and mixing, making it a great option for various occasions.
Round 9: Consumer Preferences
Popular Choices: Maker’s Mark
Maker’s Mark’s well-rounded flavor profile and reputation make it a cornerstone in bars and homes alike. In fact, reports indicate that Maker’s Mark is among the top five-selling bourbons in the U.S., appealing to newcomers and seasoned drinkers.
Popular Choices: Bulleit
Bulleit’s bold and spicy flavor has positioned it among the top-five most distributed bourbons in the market. The rise in cocktail culture particularly enhances its appeal, with over 30% of bartenders reporting Bulleit as their go-to bourbon for cocktails.
Popular Choices: Buffalo Trace
Buffalo Trace has earned a special spot on many spirits lists, ensuring repeat customers. Its growing reputation has seen it notch over 100,000 cases sold annually, thanks to its reliable quality and flavor appeal.
Verdict: Which Bourbon Reigns Supreme?
Final Thoughts on Maker’s Mark
For its undeniable smoothness and nostalgia, Maker’s Mark remains one of my favorites. It embodies traditional bourbon with approachable flavor, making it suitable for any occasion.
Final Thoughts on Bulleit
I appreciate Bulleit for its boldness and character, making it my choice when I want to mix a flavorful cocktail or impress friends. Its high rye mashbill provides a thrilling flavor experience.
Final Thoughts on Buffalo Trace
Buffalo Trace resonates with me as the consummate all-rounder. It delivers rich flavors, historical value, and great versatility, ensuring it remains a staple in my collection.
FAQ
Is Bulleit Bourbon better than Makers Mark?
It really depends on personal preference! Bulleit offers a spicier experience due to its high rye content, while Maker’s Mark delivers a smoother profile. It’s worth tasting both before making a decision!
Where does Buffalo Trace rank among bourbons?
Buffalo Trace consistently ranks as a top-tier bourbon, often cited in industry awards and consumer surveys as one of the must-try bourbons, especially for its quality and affordability.
Is Makers Mark top shelf bourbon?
Absolutely! Maker’s Mark qualifies as a top-shelf bourbon, celebrated for its quality and craftsmanship, and highly favored among bourbon drinkers everywhere.
Is Bulleit a top shelf bourbon?
Yes, Bulleit is considered top shelf by many due to its bold flavors and versatility, particularly appealing to cocktail enthusiasts. You can often find it highlighted on cocktail menus.
